Loads of businesses treat digital marketing a bit like the gas bill, so they get it set up, hand it over to someone and take it for granted that the lights are being kept on. Then half a year later they’re scratching their heads about why their Google rankings have slid right down the page and why the paid search budget has been burning away with next to nothing coming back. Picking an agency is not some small admin job to tick off, because the firm you go with can make a massive difference to how your business does online, for better or for worse.
The UK digital marketing scene is so packed that it can be tricky to know who to trust. There are thousands of agencies out there, from one-person freelance setups run from a spare bedroom in Leeds right up to big network agencies with glass offices in Shoreditch that mostly charge you for the postcode. Somewhere in the middle sit the agencies you really want to be speaking to, and tracking them down takes a fair bit more than a quick Google search and a phone call.
What Sets a Decent Agency Apart From a Forgettable One
The agencies that keep getting results tend to have a few things in common, and none of them are especially glamorous. In early chats they usually ask far more questions than they answer, they’re straight with you about timescales, which for SEO normally means admitting that proper organic growth takes months and not weeks, and they aren’t trying to flog you every single service on the menu from the first meeting.
Being open about the work is a big deal too. A good agency will show you exactly what it’s doing and the reasons behind it, instead of hiding everything behind a monthly PDF that says clicks went up 3% without explaining a thing. You ought to be able to get your head round what you’re paying for, even if you’ve never worked in marketing yourself.
Then there’s the old question of whether to go with a specialist or an all-rounder. Some agencies do a little bit of everything to an okay standard, while others have built up real depth in particular areas, whether that’s technical SEO, content strategy or paid media. Depth tends to beat breadth most of the time, and that’s especially true for businesses fighting it out in crowded search results.
Click Consult and What They Actually Do
Based in Cheshire, the Click Consult digital marketing agency has been going since 2003, which in internet terms makes them proper veterans. Their main focus is search marketing, covering both organic SEO and paid search, and they’ve built up a good name for themselves with mid-sized and larger businesses that need a properly thought-out search strategy and not some off-the-shelf package.
The interesting thing about them isn’t really the awards, even though they’ve picked up a fair few industry gongs along the way. It’s more that the way they work is rooted in search basics that hold up well over time. Algorithm updates have wiped out plenty of agencies that built everything on shaky ground, so the fact that Click Consult has stuck around this long suggests they’ve been getting enough things right to ride out all those changes.
They won’t be the right fit for every business, mind. If you’re a sole trader after a bit of basic help with social media, they probably aren’t the first place you’d go. For companies that take their search visibility seriously and want a team with the technical know-how to deal with something complicated, though, they deserve a proper look.
How to Size Up Any Agency Before Signing on the Dotted Line
Ask any agency you’re talking to for case studies from your own sector, meaning real examples of how they’ve dealt with businesses facing the same sort of problems as yours, not the usual generic success stories. Keep an ear out for how they talk about the times things went wrong as much as the wins, because any agency claiming a spotless record with every client is either being choosy with the truth or hasn’t taken on enough tough work.
Have a look at how they show up in search themselves. It might sound obvious, but if an SEO agency doesn’t rank for anything that matters, that ought to raise a few questions. The same goes for the content they put out, so check whether it really shows they know their stuff or whether it’s thin filler written to keep a content calendar ticking over.
The small print matters as well. Be careful with agencies that want to tie you into really long contracts from the start without any performance targets written into the deal, because twelve months with no break clause and no agreed KPIs isn’t much of a partnership and leaves you with nowhere to turn if it all goes badly.
Digital marketing done right is slow, can be frustrating at times and is hardly ever as exciting as agencies make it sound in their pitch decks. The businesses that get the most out of it are usually the ones that chose carefully in the first place and then stayed involved with the work, rather than leaving the whole thing to somebody else and hoping for the best.

